Films or TV programmes that are based on book originals – do you prefer reading them, or watching them?

You can probably guess which side of the fence I come down on here. The relationship you have with a book is completely different to one you have with a film. Films are a one-night stand – you find out their name, spend a little time with them, hopefully have a good time, and if you really enjoyed yourself you might call them up again sometime in the future for another brief encounter.

Reading a book is a commitment. It’s a long-term relationship. You invest days, weeks, months of your leisure time into reading a book. You develop a more deeply-invested bond with the characters, their trials, their successes, and their misery.  You also have much more scope to interpret a book as you want to, and make of it what you will.

 

When someone turns your favourite book into a film, you are presented with their interpretation. That’s what they think the characters look like, how they dress; and these are the bits they felt were important to keep in, in order to condense down that beautifully crafted piece of literature into the timeslot they have available to them. And there’s always the risk that they’ll change things that you held dear.

I do enjoy watching a screen interpretation of the books I’ve loved. I feel able to take the bits I agree with, and ignore the bits I don’t, from a secure position of knowledge about the story that I cemented with reading it. Harry Potter – by and large – I was delighted with. I missed the cheeky poltergeist Peeves, and I was quite astonished by the children’s terrible acting in the first couple of films (some didn’t improve into adulthood, either), but overall I felt they captured my version of the books very nicely, and I think lots of people agreed.

I’ve done things both ways round – I watched Gone With The Wind several hundred times before reading the book, and was staggered to learn that Scarlett has two other children from her previous marriages who were cut completely from the film. I adored Red Dwarf on the TV years before I read the two novels. It can work that way round, too – the characters and the setting have been imagined for you already, so you have them in your head before you begin.

Game of Thrones has been a different kettle of fish altogether. My relationship with the TV series has been more like the relationship I had with the books – over a long period of time, and with lots of emotional and cerebral investment in the characters, multiple interweaving storylines, and social and political themes. The creators also had a very difficult prospect ahead of them when bringing it all to a close, in that an ending is yet to be written by the original author. They worked with him (I believe) and came up with what they presented to the world last Sunday. If you’re a fan or not, you’re probably aware that it wasn’t well received by the majority of devotees, and I’ll put my hand up to being one of them. For a series that had me gasping in every one of the 72 episodes leading up to that point, I was most disgruntled to be left with a resounding “meh” by the final one.  

So I’m pinning all my hopes on the author, George RR Martin, who did a great PR job on the next book in the series this week (as if he needed to) by saying that his books will diverge significantly from the TV series. I can’t wait to get started again.

More from the Blog…

What can I actually blog about?

This is the question lots of clients have for me. Lots of business owners are aware that writing regular blog posts is one of the best ways to increase your SEO (or how high you come up on the list of results on search engines), and a great way to keep your regular...

Blood Test or Bloodshed for the Five-Year-Old?

The little one (LO) needed to have a blood test. We’ve known about this for a few months, and the appointment came through for this week. In an ideal world, this is how that first conversation would have gone: Me: So, you need to have a blood test, darling. The...

World Book Day – Be Anything You Like, Just Be Inspired

Having books in my life, from as early as I can remember, is the reason I love words and writing now. I have no doubt about that, and I’ve surrounded my own children with books from the day they were born as well. World Book Day is coming up, and I wish we'd had it...

I thought SATs couldn’t get any worse

Last year, our little boy was 6 years old, and in Year 2. Nobody told him he was doing SATs, but he knew something was up - here's the account of what was happening then: SATs: this is what they're doing to our 6-year-old. When I shared that post, the most surprising...

The Beauty of Air BnB – and Monkey Bums

There was a lot going on this half term. I’ve talked before about the challenges of working from home during the school holidays, and this one had some extra dimensions – a product launch for my client Mum to Mum VIP on Monday, two new clients who had...

It’s Valentine’s season – five ways show your business some love

It’s a fortunate coincidence that Valentine’s Day falls at this time of year, because it’s a great time to give your business some TLC. The winter months are often quieter for a lot of businesses, as customers’ wallets bounce back from the Christmas hit, and...

Working from Home with Kids – My Summer Resolutions

Back in February, I encountered the school holidays for the first time since starting my own business. I don't have enough hours to warrant the cost of holiday clubs, so the harsh reality of looking after two energetic small boys, and keeping up with all of the same...

Feel the love – why women need some Styled by Susie love in their lives

Clothes shopping is never what I think it’s going to be. I have high hopes of what I’m going to find, and how it’s going to look, and they are usually dashed. I step dispiritedly from the changing rooms, after half an hour of...

Do you really need a website?

Yes, you do. (And not just because RLC Words has recently branched out into website design, under the expert tutelage of Mr RLC Words.) I’m really rather proud of the sites I’ve produced so far though (see some here), and another lovely one went live just this...

Business Awards – why you should definitely enter them

I had a brand new experience last night – I attended the SME Buckinghamshire Business Awards 2018. It was a black tie event, and the last time I went to one of those, it was a Scottish ceilidh. I really had no idea what to expect from a business event, although I...
Share This
%d bloggers like this: